# Oasis vs Yuka: lab tests and per-category methods vs one label-based formula

> **Quick answer:** The key difference: Yuka scores packaged food and cosmetics from the label with one published formula (60% nutrition, 30% additives, 10% organic), free to scan. Oasis rates water, food, supplements and household products with 361 category methods and publishes lab results for 2,191 products; full rankings need Oasis Pro ($47 to $69.99 a year listed). Checked November 20, 2026.

- **Price:** Yuka free + Premium $10-$20/yr; Oasis free tier + Pro
- **Methods:** Yuka 1 food formula; Oasis 361 category docs
- **Lab results:** Oasis 2,191 products; Yuka none stated
- **Checked:** November 20, 2026

## Oasis and Yuka at a glance

Store details checked November 20, 2026 (US). Listed in no particular order; we don't rank apps or judge accuracy.

Haven is made by the publisher of this site. Its row uses only features we've verified in the app we ship. How we compare apps: https://havenfood.app/methodology/app-comparisons

| App | Price (US) | Platforms | Scans (as stated) | Published method | Recall alerts | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oasis | Free tier; Oasis Pro $47 to $69.99/year listed[1] | iPhone, Android[1][2] | 214,428 products in 325 categories: water, food, supplements, household[4] | Yes, per category (361 docs)[5] | Not stated | November 20, 2026 |
| Yuka | Free; Premium $10 to $20/year[9][10] | iPhone, Android[9][10] | 4 million foods, 2 million cosmetics (listing)[9][12] | Yes: 60/30/10 formula[11] | FDA recall pop-up and email, reported[15] | November 20, 2026 |
| [Haven (ours)](https://havenfood.app/haven) | In development; join the waitlist | In development; join the waitlist | Packaged foods, by barcode or label photo | Not published yet | Push alert when a recall names a barcode you scanned (FDA, USDA FSIS) | November 20, 2026 |

"Not stated" means we couldn't find it on the app's listing or website. It doesn't mean the app lacks the feature.

People on Reddit often ask which of these two to use [18], and the question is fair: both publish how they score, but they score in very different ways. Yuka reads the label. Oasis adds lab tests and writes a separate method for each kind of product. This page sets out what each says about itself; we don't test apps or judge accuracy.

## Price

- **Yuka:** free to scan; Premium is $10, $15 or $20 a year on the US App Store and $10 to $20 on Google Play [9][10]. Yuka says it runs no ads and is funded by its users [14].
- **Oasis:** free to download. Its listing says "Free: access all lab results and reports," and lists Oasis Pro at $47, $59.99 or $69.99 a year, with weekly ($4.99) and monthly plans. It says it charges "to fund expensive lab testing and remain independent—no ads" [1]. Its FAQ says it uses affiliate links [3].

## Platforms and countries

Both run on iPhone and Android. Oasis: 4.8 stars from 13,567 US iPhone ratings; on Google Play it is listed as "Oasis - Water Rankings", 4.6 stars, 100K+ installs [1][2]. Yuka: 4.8 from 102,574 US ratings; 4.7 on Google Play with 10M+ installs [9][10].

Oasis's tap-water data is for US locations [4]; it doesn't list countries. Yuka says its database is shared across all the countries where it's available [9].

## How each scores

**Yuka: one formula for all food.** 60% nutritional quality (Nutri-Score), 30% additives, 10% organic. A high-risk additive caps the score at 49 out of 100 [11].

**Oasis: a method per category.** Oasis publishes 361 scoring documents on a 1 to 100 scale, one per product category from bottled water to protein bars, last updated October 29, 2026 when we checked [5]. Every score starts at 100 and attributes add or subtract points. Testing sets the ceiling: an untested product can't score above 85, and two results over a legal limit cap the score at 30 [5]. The limits it compares lab results against are listed with their sources [6].

## Where the data comes from

Yuka scores from packaging information added by contributors or manufacturers [13]; it states 4 million foods and 2 million cosmetics on its listing, 3.6 million foods in its help center [9][12].

Oasis says ingredients, nutrition and claims come "from the brand's own US label and site" [4]. It states 214,428 verified products in 325 categories, with 2,770 published lab reports covering 2,191 products, and says it tests for heavy metals, microplastics, PFAS and "300+ contaminants" [4]. Most Oasis products have no lab report, so their scores rest on the category method alone.

## What each says about its limits

Yuka says its additive ratings are its opinion, with a precautionary approach, that it can't guarantee absolute accuracy, and that people with allergies should always check the label [13]. Oasis says its "scores are not a medical verdict," that scores "reflect available testing data," that scores in different categories can't be compared, and that its scoring system "is subject to change" [5].

## Recalls

Food Safety Magazine reported that Yuka shows a pop-up linking the FDA recall notice when you scan a recalled product [15]. Oasis doesn't state a recall feature [4]. See [how to check if a food is recalled](/guides/how-to-check-if-food-is-recalled).

## Lawsuits (allegations, not findings)

- **Oasis:** Drink LMNT, Inc. sued Live Oasis, LLC and Cormac Hayden in the US District Court for the District of Delaware on June 10, 2026 (No. 1:26-cv-00677) [7]. The complaint alleges Oasis treated a lead concentration measured per kilogram of powder as a per-serving amount and told followers LMNT had "seven times the legal limit of lead"; claims include Lanham Act false advertising and defamation [8]. On October 5, 2026, the defendants filed a motion to dismiss. The case was pending, with no ruling on the public docket, when we checked on November 20, 2026 [7].
- **Yuka:** Goya Foods sued Yuca Corp. in the District of New Jersey on May 28, 2025 (No. 2:25-cv-05976), alleging false advertising over Yuka's ratings [16]. On February 20, 2026, the court administratively terminated the case after the parties reported a settlement [17].

## Which to pick if…

- **Your concern is lead, PFAS or microplastics:** Oasis is the one that publishes lab results [4].
- **You check water, filters or supplements:** Oasis covers them; Yuka doesn't.
- **You want nutrition and additives in packaged food, for free:** Yuka [11].
- **You want one rule you can learn once:** Yuka's single formula; Oasis's method changes with the category.
- **You want recall pop-ups:** only Yuka has a reported recall feature [15].

More: our [Oasis review](/guides/oasis-review), [Yuka review](/guides/yuka-review), [Oasis alternatives](/alternatives/oasis) and [Yuka alternatives](/alternatives/yuka).

## Where Haven fits

Haven is made by the publisher of this site. It's a food and ingredient scanner app. It is in development: not in the App Store or Google Play yet, and the waitlist is open.

In the current build, on iPhone and Android:

- **Barcode scan:** Scans UPC and EAN barcodes on packaged food with the phone camera, or lets you type the number.
- **Score reasons:** Lists each line that raises or lowers the score with its reason; lines from a regulator, study or recall link to that source.
- **Sources:** Shows the source link for each flagged ingredient, recall and lab result; sources open in the browser.
- **Additive rules by country:** Shows how the US (federal and some states), the EU, the UK, Canada and Australia/New Zealand treat an additive, quoting the rule each status comes from.
- **Recall alerts:** Sends a push notification when an official recall names the exact barcode of a product you scanned or added to your kitchen.
- **Allergens and diets:** Checks each product against the 9 major US allergens, 11 diets (vegan, gluten-free, keto and others) and your own list of ingredients to avoid.
- **Lab results:** Where public testing of that exact product exists (for example lead in baby food), shows the measured value, the official limit and who tested it.
- **No account:** Works without an account or sign-in.

What is Haven? https://havenfood.app/haven

## Common questions

### Is Oasis better than Yuka?

We don't rank apps or judge accuracy. Yuka applies one formula to packaged food, weighted toward nutrition. Oasis writes a method per product category and folds in lab results where it has them. Both publish how they score.

### Is Oasis or Yuka cheaper?

Yuka scans for free, with Premium at $10 to $20 a year. Oasis's listing says lab results and reports are free, and lists Oasis Pro at $47, $59.99 or $69.99 a year, plus weekly and monthly plans. Checked November 20, 2026.

### Has Oasis been sued?

Yes. Drink LMNT, Inc. sued Live Oasis, LLC in federal court in Delaware on June 10, 2026 (No. 1:26-cv-00677), alleging false advertising and defamation over a lead claim. The claims are allegations, not findings; a motion to dismiss was filed on October 5, 2026, and the case was pending when we checked.

### Has Yuka been sued?

Goya Foods sued Yuca Corp. in New Jersey federal court in May 2025 (No. 2:25-cv-05976). The court administratively terminated the case on February 20, 2026, after the parties reported a settlement.

### Does Oasis test water and Yuka not?

Oasis rates bottled water, filters and tap water, and its Google Play listing is titled "Oasis - Water Rankings". Yuka rates packaged food and cosmetics.

## Sources

1. [Oasis: Personal Health (App Store listing, US)](https://apps.apple.com/us/app/id6499478532), Apple App Store
2. [Oasis - Water Rankings (Google Play listing, US)](https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.liveoasis.oasis&hl=en_US&gl=US), Google Play
3. [Oasis home page and FAQ](https://www.oasishealth.app/), Oasis
4. [Open data](https://www.oasishealth.app/data), Oasis
5. [Scoring documentation](https://www.oasishealth.app/scoring), Oasis
6. [Levels & Limits](https://www.oasishealth.app/levels-and-limits), Oasis
7. [Drink LMNT, Inc. v. Live Oasis, LLC, No. 1:26-cv-00677 (D. Del.)](https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/73465014/drink-lmnt-inc-v-live-oasis-llc/), CourtListener
8. [Complaint, Drink LMNT, Inc. v. Live Oasis, LLC](https://courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/lmnt-lawsuit.pdf), Courthouse News Service
9. [Yuka - Food & Cosmetic Scanner (App Store listing, US)](https://apps.apple.com/us/app/id1092799236), Apple App Store
10. [Yuka - Food & Cosmetic Scanner (Google Play listing, US)](https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=io.yuka.android&hl=en_US&gl=US), Google Play
11. [How are food products rated?](https://help.yuka.io/l/en/article/ijzgfvi1jq-how-are-food-products-scored), Yuka Help Center
12. [How many products are rated by Yuka?](https://help.yuka.io/l/en/article/g761zika9n-how-many-products-are-rated-by-yuka), Yuka Help Center
13. [What are Yuka's limitations?](https://help.yuka.io/l/en/article/wz3cbbztf3-what-are-yuka-s-limitations), Yuka Help Center
14. [Independence](https://yuka.io/en/independence/), Yuka
15. [Mobile Label-Scanning App Communicates Food Product Recall Information](https://food-safety.com/articles/9217-mobile-label-scanning-app-communicates-food-product-recall-information), Food Safety Magazine
16. [Goya Foods, Inc. v. Yuca Corp., No. 2:25-cv-05976 (D.N.J.)](https://dockets.justia.com/docket/new-jersey/njdce/2:2025cv05976/570739), Justia Dockets
17. [Goya Foods, Inc. v. Yuca Corp. docket (administrative termination order, Feb 20, 2026)](https://www.pacermonitor.com/public/case/58259452/GOYA_FOODS,_INC_v_YUCA_CORP), PacerMonitor
18. [r/ultraprocessedfood discussion comparing food scanner apps](https://www.reddit.com/r/ultraprocessedfood/comments/1seblmn/), Reddit

---

Source page: https://havenfood.app/compare/oasis-vs-yuka
Last reviewed: November 20, 2026
Publisher: Haven (https://havenfood.app). General information, not medical advice.
