Quick answer
Synthetic dyes such as Red 40, Yellow 5 and Blue 1 must be listed by name on US ingredient labels, so they're easy to spot. Colors made from sources like beets, paprika, turmeric, spirulina or fruit and vegetable juice are approved separately and can be listed by name, as 'colored with ...', or simply as 'color added' or 'artificial color'. Carmine, a red made from insects, must always be named.
- Synthetic dyes on labelsListed by name, e.g. Red 40
- Other colors on labelsBy name, or 'color added'
- Carmine / cochinealMust be named
- FDA phase-out requestApril 2025
Last verified . 11 sources cited. How we verify. General information, not medical advice.
On this page
Whether you’re avoiding synthetic dyes for a child, for a diet, or just out of preference, the US ingredient label gives you most of what you need. The trick is knowing that the rules treat two groups of colors differently.
The two groups of colors
US law splits color additives into two groups:
- Colors subject to certification. These are the synthetic dyes, like Red 40, Yellow 5 and Blue 1.
- Colors exempt from certification. These include colors made from vegetables, fruits, spices, algae and minerals. They’re still approved one by one, under their own rules 1.
How to spot a synthetic dye
This part is simple. A certified color must be declared by its name in the ingredient list. Makers can drop the “FD&C” and the “No.”, so you’ll usually see something like “Red 40” or “Yellow 5”. The insoluble form must say “Lake”, as in “Blue 1 Lake” 1.
So if you see a color name with a number, it’s a synthetic dye.
What replaces them
When a company drops a synthetic dye, it usually switches to a color from the exempt group. Common ones, each with its own FDA rule:
| Color you want | Common replacement | Its name in the FDA rule |
|---|---|---|
| Red, pink | Beet powder 2 | Dehydrated beets (beet powder) |
| Red, purple | Fruit or vegetable juice 87 | Fruit juice; vegetable juice |
| Orange | Paprika or annatto 43 | Paprika; annatto extract |
| Yellow | Turmeric 5 | Turmeric |
| Blue, green | Spirulina 6 | Spirulina extract |
| Deep red | Carmine 9 | Cochineal extract; carmine |
In April 2025, the FDA also said it was fast-tracking review of more colors from natural sources, including calcium phosphate, galdieria extract blue, gardenia blue and butterfly pea flower extract 10.
The catch: “artificial color” and “color added”
Here’s where labels get confusing. Colors in the exempt group don’t have to be named. They can be listed as “Artificial Color”, “Artificial Color Added” or “Color Added”, or by name as “Colored with ” or ” color” 1.
That means:
- “Red 40” on a label always means the synthetic dye.
- “Artificial color” or “color added” can mean a color from the exempt group, including one made from vegetables. It doesn’t by itself tell you which.
- Carmine is the exception. It must always be named as “carmine” or “cochineal extract” 9. That matters if you avoid animal products, because carmine is made from insects.
It’s getting easier
The FDA has asked food companies to remove six synthetic dyes from the food supply, including Red 40, Yellow 5 and Blue 1 10. It keeps a public tracker of company pledges. Several large food makers have promised to remove certified colors from some or all of their US products 11. Expect more products with beet, paprika or spirulina on the label over the next year or two.
Common questions
Does 'artificial color' always mean a synthetic dye?
No. Under FDA rules, colors that don't need batch certification, including ones made from vegetables or spices, may also be listed as 'artificial color' or 'color added'. Synthetic certified dyes must be listed by their own name, such as Red 40.
Is carmine vegan?
No. Carmine and cochineal extract are made from cochineal insects, and FDA rules require them to be named on the label.
Are colors from plants always safer?
Not necessarily. Each color additive is approved for specific uses on its own evidence. This guide is about reading labels, not ranking safety.
Sources
Every fact on this page comes from these public sources. Numbers in the text link here.
- 21 CFR 101.22: labeling of spices, flavorings, colorings and chemical preservatives eCFR
- 21 CFR 73.40: dehydrated beets (beet powder) eCFR
- 21 CFR 73.30: annatto extract eCFR
- 21 CFR 73.340: paprika eCFR
- 21 CFR 73.600: turmeric eCFR
- 21 CFR 73.530: spirulina extract eCFR
- 21 CFR 73.260: vegetable juice eCFR
- 21 CFR 73.250: fruit juice eCFR
- 21 CFR 73.100: cochineal extract; carmine eCFR
- HHS, FDA to Phase Out Petroleum-Based Synthetic Dyes in Nation's Food Supply U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Apr 22, 2025
- Tracking Food Industry Pledges to Remove Petroleum Based Food Dyes U.S. Food and Drug Administration
General information, not medical, nutrition or legal advice. If you have a food allergy or a health condition, talk to your doctor. Spotted a mistake? Email corrections@havenfood.app and read our corrections policy.